Civilianized safety practitioners reduce crime and disorder: Evidence from a quasiexperimental evaluation in San Francisco

Clicks: 23
ID: 327394
2026
Free PDF
Article Quality & Performance Metrics
Overall Quality
Not rated
Combines reader engagement with the AI quality analysis. This article has not been analysed, so there is no overall score — reader engagement is measured and shown alongside.
AI Quality Assessment
Not analyzed
Readership in this journal
Steady

Ranked #47 of 151 articles by views in PNAS nexus

Most read Least read

Bar heights use a square-root scale. Only the 120 most-read articles are drawn; the journal has 151 in total.

Mint this article as an NFT
Not yet minted

Create a permanent, verifiable on-chain record of this article on the Scimatic Network. The NFT is held in your Journament account, and you can withdraw it to your own wallet at any time.

5 SUSD one-off · no wallet required
Sign in to mint
Abstract
Cities across the United States are experimenting with civilian-led alternatives to policing, yet rigorous evidence of their effectiveness remains scarce. This study evaluates a large-scale civilianized public safety program in San Francisco that deploys unarmed "safety practitioners" to high-crime intersections to provide consistent presence, de-escalation, and service referrals in place of traditional law enforcement. Using a generalized synthetic control design covering 624 intersections from 2018 to 2023, we estimate the causal impact of practitioner deployment on reported crime. We find that deployments significantly reduced total and behavioral health-related crimes, with smaller yet meaningful reductions in drug and violent crimes, and no change in property crime. These effects persisted across robustness checks comparing daytime (operating) to nighttime (nonoperating) hours, suggesting that observed declines are attributable to practitioner presence rather than secular trends. The findings indicate that civilianized safety practitioners-drawn largely from communities affected by incarceration, addiction, and homelessness-can function as capable guardians who lower public disorder without relying on coercive authority. By embedding trusted, nonpolice actors in high-need public spaces, cities may improve safety while reducing harmful police contact and expanding workforce opportunities for people historically excluded from the formal economy.
Reference Key
openalex_W7204878326 Use this key to autocite in the manuscript while using SciMatic Manuscript Manager or Thesis Manager
Authors Forrest Stuart, Caylin Louis Moore, Patrick Janulis
Are you one of these authors? Claim your profile
Journal PNAS nexus
Year 2026
DOI
10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag275
URL
https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article-pdf/5/9/pgag275/70834654/pgag275.pdf
Keywords Keywords not found

Citations

No citations found. To add a citation, contact the admin at info@scimatic.org

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment on this article.