TOP-GAN: Stain-free cancer cell classification using deep learning with a small training set.

Clicks: 236
ID: 41149
2019
Article Quality & Performance Metrics
Overall Quality Improving Quality
82.1 /100
Combines engagement data with AI-assessed academic quality
AI Quality Assessment 🥈 High Quality
88.0 /100
Academic Rigor 92.0%
Novelty 80.0%
Clarity 90.0%
Key Strengths
  • Innovative approach combining transfer learning and GANs
  • High classification accuracies reported
  • Addresses a critical problem of small training sets in medical imaging
Areas for Improvement
  • Limited information on the specific architecture of the GAN used
  • Further validation on more diverse cell types would strengthen the findings
  • Discussion of potential limitations of the approach could be expanded
AI Recommendations

Provide more detailed information about the GAN architecture and training process. Include a more thorough discussion of the limitations of the proposed method and potential areas for future research. Consider expanding the validation to include a wider range of cell types and imaging modalities.

Enhanced v2.0 Analysis NISO/DORA Compliant
NISO/DORA Compliant
High Impact
📊 Established
Topic Trend
2025 Relevance
Relevance
0%
Importance
0%
Authorship
Unknown
Authors
0
Diversity
0%
Research Integrity
COPE Standards
Integrity
0%
Innovation
0%
Interdisciplinary Value
🔀 Cross-disciplinary
75%
Practical Impact Potential
Real-world Applications
85%
Enhanced Evaluation v2.0: Following NISO RP-25-2016, DORA 2025, and COPE assessment standards with 13 quality dimensions.
Abstract
We propose a new deep learning approach for medical imaging that copes with the problem of a small training set, the main bottleneck of deep learning, and apply it for classification of healthy and cancer cell lines acquired by quantitative phase imaging. The proposed method, called transferring of pre-trained generative adversarial network (TOP-GAN), is hybridization between transfer learning and generative adversarial networks (GANs). Healthy cells and cancer cells of different metastatic potential have been imaged by low-coherence off-axis holography. After the acquisition, the optical path delay maps of the cells are extracted and directly used as inputs to the networks. In order to cope with the small number of classified images, we use GANs to train a large number of unclassified images from another cell type (sperm cells). After this preliminary training, we change the last layers of the network and design automatic classifiers for the correct cell type (healthy/primary cancer/metastatic cancer) with 90-99% accuracies, although small training sets of down to several images are used. These results are better in comparison to other classic methods that aim at coping with the same problem of a small training set. We believe that our approach makes the combination of holographic microscopy and deep learning networks more accessible to the medical field by enabling a rapid, automatic and accurate classification in stain-free imaging flow cytometry. Furthermore, our approach is expected to be applicable to many other medical image classification tasks, suffering from a small training set.
Reference Key
rubin2019topganmedical Use this key to autocite in the manuscript while using SciMatic Manuscript Manager or Thesis Manager
Authors Rubin, Moran;Stein, Omer;Turko, Nir A;Nygate, Yoav;Roitshtain, Darina;Karako, Lidor;Barnea, Itay;Giryes, Raja;Shaked, Natan T;
Journal Medical image analysis
Year 2019
DOI
S1361-8415(19)30056-8
URL
Keywords

Citations

No citations found. To add a citation, contact the admin at info@scimatic.org

No comments yet. Be the first to comment on this article.